Scoring for pitching

[rcankosy]

Which column is the finished number, the balanced number?

Column X = Game Score balanced

[Dan Wood]

Guys, just wanted to say you for the effort. I appreciate it, as I am sure the rest of the league does. The only problem that I have with it, is that most pitchers seem to have a decrease in their scoring. There is a slight shuffle overall in the top 5, but from where I stand, I'm still going to have to say we stick with what we have. I'm throwing it out to everyone else to get some dialogue going.

Thanks
D

[h4cheng]

Dan, I understand the concern, but I think it's a bit misplaced. The impact of the scoring change is -0.1% for all pitchers.

[Colby]

Dan, I understand the concern, but I think it's a bit misplaced. The impact of the scoring change is -0.1% for all pitchers.

That's a small change... I think the major problem people had with the scoring was the holes in the pitching stats.  You could compare two SP outings and know that the one was superior but it scored far less points due to GB and IP.

[h4cheng]

That's a small change... I think the major problem people had with the scoring was the holes in the pitching stats.  You could compare two SP outings and know that the one was superior but it scored far less points due to GB and IP.

Let's take the Liriano no hitter an example:

Points under current system: 27
Game Score Balanced: 124.5
Points under the proposed system: 75.75

Evidently, the proposed system takes greater consideration the actual outcome of the pitching performance.

[rcankosy]

Is it time for the RC to officially vote on this?  In my opinion, we should give the RC 7-10 days to vote on this and put this to bed.

[Colby]

Is it time for the RC to officially vote on this?  In my opinion, we should give the RC 7-10 days to vote on this and put this to bed.

 :iatp:

[Dan Wood]

Can we even do it now since we are using Fantrax?

[h4cheng]

Can we even do it now since we are using Fantrax?

yes

all the components of game score are in fantrax.

[Dan Wood]

I vote nay to new scoring - keep old scoring