0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
How many people should be on the staff?Should there be a minimum amount of time (24, 48, 72 hours) that a trade should sit as pending until it is sent back to the league?How many people need to vote on a trade?How many approvals are needed to pass a trade?How many vetoes are required to reject a trade?1248 hours854
I think I have had a change of heart. I think sending it out of house may cause more problems than it solves. I propose the following.1. 6 members on the TC - one from each division2.Any divisional rival that makes a deal cannot have his trade approved or vetoed by the mebers of the TC that are in his division.3. 3 approval votes or two vetoes4. Past trades should not be considered. Values fluctuate over the course of a season and team needs change. Just because so and so was trade for player X two months ago, doesn't mean he merits that return now. Plus situations vary.Example - I couldn't give Adam Lind away last year5. a short summary as to why you are making this trade, and what you expect it will do for your team.6. No one but the TC and the trading partners can post within a trade posting. It turns into pure chaos. 7. Any member of the TC that was involved in trade talks with a team involving a player that was dealt to another team may not vote on a trade - it is a conflict of interest.8. Any trade vetoed needs to have an explanation why, and both GMs should be given a chance to defend their move.That is just my two cents. Since we are already mid season - we already a system in place. I would more than happily represent the NL Central
I think I have had a change of heart. I think sending it out of house may cause more problems than it solves. I propose the following.1. 6 members on the TC - one from each division2.Any divisional rival that makes a deal cannot have his trade approved or vetoed by the mebers of the TC that are in his division.3. 3 approval votes or two vetoes4. Past trades should not be considered. Values fluctuate over the course of a season and team needs change. Just because so and so was trade for player X two months ago, doesn't mean he merits that return now. Plus situations vary.Example - I couldn't give Adam Lind away last year5. a short summary as to why you are making this trade, and what you expect it will do for your team.6. No one but the TC and the trading partners can post within a trade posting. It turns into pure chaos. 7. Any member of the TC that was involved in trade talks with a team involving a player that was dealt to another team may not vote on a trade - it is a conflict of interest.8. Any trade vetoed needs to have an explanation why, and both GMs should be given a chance to defend their move.
I don't think # 5 is necessary unless the trade garners a veto vote.