0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
That scoring system is way out of my league. I believe how you did it is the closest to what we are looking for. And if it was up to me, I dont know a person like you colby that finds info. and researches the info any better then you. So what I read on this Rules Committee Page is the best around for Fantasy Baseball!! And thats another reason, I really enjoy this league!
My issue may not be with defense for catchers after all. I figured out why Mauer is less than Sandoval and Inge and V-Mart are rated the same. There is no deduction for outs of any kind, or any measurement of how often a player gets a hit. Just take a look at the AVG and OBP alongside the RC and PTS and you will see that OBP has little correlation.
Our stats are going to be comparable total RC rather than a ratio like RC/27 that would include how many outs a player makes. If you look at Mauer's Points/Game in our system, he's rightfully the top catcher last season. With that said, there will undoubtedly be some discrepancies between the resulting rankings and what might have been expected - this is why I think it's really important we make a decision as soon as possible on passing the scoring system (something I tried to stress a while back).I would like to pass a scoring system by tomorrow if at all possible. I am going to tweak it and see how the negative weighted inclusion of OUTS, STRIKEOUTS, and/or AB affects it.
If you're going to include one of those 3 as a negative, I'd suggest outs.