Sorry to be the party pooper here, but I can't justify this deal in terms of fantasy points, talent, or salary.
Durran, P-2025 ($0.5m) 28 years old
2024 22.4 ppg
2023 18.8 ppg
Gurriel 2027 ($5.5m) 31 years old
2024 14.5 ppg
2023 14.8 ppg
2022 14.9 ppg
Webb 2026 ($0.7m) 31 years old
2024 8.5 ppg
2023 8.4 ppg
2022 7.9 ppg
Durran has clearly been the better player the last 2 years and will likely continue to be, since Gurriel's production seems to have been established. Durran could command a high salary next year, but the Yankees have more than enough cap space ($94m in 2026) to pay it. Webb is a average RP, but free agency hasn't even started, so the Yankees could most likely get an equal product in the marketplace.
:veto: