Need New Scoring System

[Lindner]

I understand the concern. My problem is that having a poor scoring system discourages new members and makes the league worse as a whole. Only 1 of the 14 voters chose to keep the previous scoring system. I am in the same boat and made several moves because of the scoring system. I think it is better to have a more accurate scoring system in place though. If there was more objection to the switch over I would agree to the argument.

  X 100


If the scoring system was somewhat decent, I would be against changing it.  Our scoring system is absolutely terrible though.  The vast majority would like to see it change and it's not because it would help their team...

[fperric]

i agree with chris on this.  i think the save is getting a little undervalued in these discussions and the hold a little overvalued.  we have to remember that while there are some young up and coming closers earning holds in a set-up role, there are also a ton of also rans, has beens and never weres who couldn't hold a closers role for a week, let alone a season who are racking up holds. 

[fperric]

having said that, for what it is worth, i would also vote for the 4th system based on the reality and balance of the final rankings.