Home
Staff
View the memberlist
Search For Members
Portal
Mentions
League Openings
League Search
Login
Register
Leagues
ProFSL: Pro Fantasy Sports Leagues
»
Fantasy Leagues
»
MLB Leagues
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball: Archives
(Moderators:
indiansnation
,
Vik
,
EastCoastGonzo
) »
Internal or External Trade Committee?
« previous
next »
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Down
Author
Topic: Internal or External Trade Committee? (Read 1049 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
kenny
MVP
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2653
Bonus inPoints: 1
Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
on:
June 29, 2011, 11:34:12 PM »
I see other leagues have discussed the possibility of utilizing a trade committee utilizing outside members (the ProFSL TC or PTC). See this thread for Franchise GM League's discussion of this topic:
http://www.profsl.com/smf/index.php?topic=24345.0
I have mixed feelings on this as both options have their pros and cons. Letting outside members vote on trades may eliminate the possibility of biases, but they may also not know the real value of a player in this league. Yes, they are supposed to be well-versed in each leagues rules, but how effective can that really be without participating in it (in a league with custom rules)?
While I do have my opinions, this is definitely open for discussion and I'm open-minded.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Orange Country
Legend
Join Date: May 2011
Posts: 14334
Bonus inPoints: 1281
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #1 on:
June 30, 2011, 01:32:56 AM »
Since Shelby wants to help you out Kenny, ask his opinion as well. In my opinion, the PROFSL TC can be an asset to our league and I would endorse it as it is the best people picked by Colby himself. Now, this would eliminate Dave, me, and whomever else serves on it when the league opens soon. The trade committee is also responsible for making sure each move is legal within cap and roster parameters so we would still have a role, just not as big of one. Yes, we would know the rules the best, but there are some vets in PROFSL that really can look at a trade with a bit more experienced eyes and gauge a bit better with having the rules in mind.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Corey
Guest
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #2 on:
June 30, 2011, 02:03:40 AM »
I vote external
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
hank
All-Star
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 1019
Bonus inPoints: 0
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #3 on:
June 30, 2011, 02:26:17 AM »
External.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
There are lies, there are outrageous lies, and there are statistics.
---
Mark Twain
molinator
MVP
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 4085
Bonus inPoints: 0
:RMA:
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #4 on:
June 30, 2011, 09:15:02 AM »
External
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
sdobelman21
Guest
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #5 on:
June 30, 2011, 05:08:42 PM »
Wouldn't an external TC be a little bit of a burden on the members of the TC. I'm sure that the people on that TC already have enough things to do given their responsibilities on the website. I would just hate for people to be burdened with a league the are not affiliated with, because I know I really wouldn't want to be responsible for a league I wasn't involved in.
I'm fine either way just wanted to throw my 2 cents out there.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
kenny
MVP
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2653
Bonus inPoints: 1
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #6 on:
June 30, 2011, 06:52:10 PM »
The external TC is comprised of volunteers and do not necessarily have other responsibilities on this website. They already know this is for other leagues.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Shelby
MVP
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 4114
Bonus inPoints: 0
:NYJL:
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #7 on:
June 30, 2011, 06:54:29 PM »
With an external TC, no problems with a trade approved by the TC while that is unfair. no member may say that the one who vetoed protect its interests ... etc.
As noted above, the members of Profsl TC doesn't know the rules and the value of players in this league, what is true and can be a big problem but I saw that Corey and Fantasyguru were interested in joining Profsl the TC. If two members of the league are part of Profsl TC, we can count on them to explain, underline, remember the rules and values of the players.
I vote external TC
«
Last Edit: July 01, 2011, 06:56:34 AM by Shelby
»
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
mcmccullough
Guest
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #8 on:
July 01, 2011, 02:19:55 AM »
I would vote external. I feel that eliminates bias, and I'm the type who thinks a veto is only used if the trade can be harmful to the integrity of the league, and I don't feel an external TC has to have the in-depth knowledge necessarily to know whether a trade can hurt the league's integrity as a whole.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Up
« previous
next »
ProFSL: Pro Fantasy Sports Leagues
»
Fantasy Leagues
»
MLB Leagues
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball: Archives
(Moderators:
indiansnation
,
Vik
,
EastCoastGonzo
) »
Internal or External Trade Committee?
Forum Search
Quick Profile
Username:
Password:
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Did you miss your
activation email
?
Chat Room
indiansnation
:
That had to be one of the best hockey playoff games I seen this yr
Today
at 12:32:34 AM
indiansnation
:
Anybody want to talk trade
Today
at 12:33:26 AM
BayAreaBallers
:
stars are a tough team
Today
at 12:33:29 AM
indiansnation
:
It was just amazing how Edmonton was leading and then all of a sudden 2 period starts and Dallas just took over after that and just kicked Edmonton ass
Today
at 12:35:55 AM
Daddy
:
Flyers have the 12th overall pick & whatever Florida finishes with.
Today
at 01:09:39 AM
Daddy
:
We are open for business.
Today
at 01:10:32 AM
BayAreaBallers
:
sharks could be interested in those picks
Today
at 01:16:53 AM
STLBlues91
:
STL will be open for business as well
Today
at 01:23:26 AM
ldsjayhawk
:
@Daddy are you intending to trade all of your picks in NHL as well or different strategy there?
Today
at 11:25:13 AM
indiansnation
:
Penguins our interested in tradeing
Today
at 01:21:24 PM
Daddy
:
@Cris ive got 3 first rounders including 2025. Ive got 11 draft picks for the first time in years.
Today
at 01:39:03 PM
Daddy
:
Them babies burning a hole in my pocket.
Today
at 01:39:21 PM
Daddy
:
Its not that i dont like them but i want to add specific things and idk how the draft will shake out, also there are always teams wanting to invest heavy.
Today
at 01:40:27 PM
Daddy
:
We usually match in what our needs are. Then i see those teams stack like twenty picks and make magic. While i make my own magic.
Today
at 01:41:29 PM
Daddy
:
Connor McDavid deserves a haul. If Edmonton is moving him. Philly is armed to the teeth.
Today
at 01:42:13 PM
Daddy
:
Edmonton would also be armed to the teeth. Our draft is just a few days after the real one. We aint got time to ho hum. Its bout to be go time.
Today
at 01:44:09 PM
Daddy
:
You interested in The Flyers draft picks. I need names. I need pms. By 6/2 my picks will belong to some very fortunate franchise.
Today
at 01:47:39 PM
Daddy
:
Some of you guys have known me for fourteen years or more. I am a very reliable source for draft picks no matter the sport.
Today
at 01:55:39 PM
BayAreaBallers
:
what exactly are u looking for
Today
at 01:59:10 PM
Daddy
:
Depends on the team. Each one has something different. G, C, D, Crap we need wingers, i prefer guys that play both LW/RW. Im looking to improve. Thats always what im looking for. But to do so in a way that my partner also improves.
Today
at 02:02:32 PM
Daddy
:
You can build a dominant team without dominating every trade or even any trade. Doesn't matter what you give up if you get what you see as a key piece.
Today
at 02:03:49 PM
Daddy
:
Edmonton and LA are the leaders for my picks. LA unfortunately has no GM and by the time one sacs up im going to probably have dealt.
Today
at 02:05:53 PM
Daddy
:
You know we speak like this is boxing. Like there is a physical contest and you here me joking about foots etc. but we including myself are couch jockeys.
Today
at 02:08:39 PM
Daddy
:
Smack talk comes with sports. Ask about Kobe. Ask about Jordan. Ask about most of the greats. We are boxing gents. Mental boxing. From our phones and computers.
Today
at 02:09:52 PM
Daddy
:
I dont mean to bruise anyone's vagina. I cant help myself. Im a habitual vagina bruiser. Sincerely.
Today
at 02:11:08 PM
OUDAN
:
Imagine lying to all of us like that lollll\
Today
at 03:48:54 PM
Daddy
:
Up yours Danno
Today
at 04:16:28 PM
OUDAN
:
Hahaha
Today
at 04:22:07 PM
Daddy
:
Takes a certain kind of guy to even do dynasty and unfortunately many of them are.. umm "sensitive" is a good word. I am a lot of personality, but im very good at what i do. I might suck at everything else but in dynasty fantasy i am ELITE.
Today
at 04:29:57 PM
Daddy
:
As both an owner & moderator. It im ok letting you know about it.
Today
at 04:30:41 PM
Daddy
:
Its ok to be diverse. Dont chat
Today
at 04:31:36 PM
Daddy
:
Close the chat and just run your team.
Today
at 04:31:59 PM
Daddy
:
In dynasty fantasy i have the Mamba mentality and there are others like me.
Today
at 04:33:49 PM
Daddy
:
You own a baseball team for ten years and get mad you have to throw 35 innings pitched. In a week. Of baseball. Da fuq? No. Get out. Dont want you.
Today
at 04:36:25 PM
Daddy
:
Fuq u been doing? Try art or some Crap. Take up painting. Ten years you cant field a starting rotation? Da fuq is you illiterate?
Today
at 04:38:27 PM
Daddy
:
PLAYSTATION/XBOX = EA Sports (its in the game!
)
Today
at 04:40:06 PM
Daddy
:
The rest of you join my big mouth ass and lets play ball.
Today
at 04:41:03 PM
Daddy
:
Hockey fan much
[link]
NHL LIVE is fantasy hockey on illegal substances. Just like NFL/MLB LIVE it offers a unique perspective on "modern day" fantasy sport experience.
Today
at 05:27:47 PM
Daddy
:
NHL LIVE owners here are your spreadsheets
[link]
you can see your Franchises, your availability cap, your RFAs, all of it. Make your plans. Talk yo talk. Be ready.
Today
at 05:50:15 PM
STLBlues91
:
I will be around the rest of the night. I will finish correcting 5 spreadsheets and then they all should match. I am officially on summer vacation
Today
at 06:35:36 PM
Daddy
:
Shot out to YURmom. The first female of LIVE as its only female LIVE GM. Thats a keeper @Mt_Crushmore!
Today
at 09:23:01 PM
Daddy
:
#Chicks dig da dynasty
Today
at 09:24:43 PM
Daddy
:
Shot out to all actively bidding in the Nico Hoerner sweepstakes!
[link]
MLB LIVE never sleeps.
Today
at 09:29:27 PM
Daddy
:
Shot out to @jmntl82
[link]
congratulations on your first of many LIVE trades.
Today
at 09:31:14 PM
Daddy
:
Well damn.. congratulations on your second trade in the last fifteen minutes.
Bartender i will have what he's having.
Today
at 09:37:13 PM
IndianaBuc
:
I’ll have a double.
Today
at 09:38:53 PM
jmntl82
:
Stay tuned, we're building something over here in Detroit
Today
at 09:43:10 PM
Brent
:
PM sent Detroit
Today
at 09:51:02 PM
Rhino7
:
Bartender pour me another
Today
at 09:56:30 PM
Daddy
:
We are building something. In every sport. Non stop. Its what we do.
Today
at 10:11:31 PM