0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
@Flash: It seems like you are missing the entire point. What makes the EDR system unique is that it gives value to the draft and we all agree that the draft is one of the things that makes this league so special. We already have very few prospects that can be signed in FA and with these changes the Yankees of this world get a huge advantage by being allowed to stow their signings in this EDR roster. I am saying that this rule gives further advantage to teams with ample salary cap because now they can invest heavily on signing bonuses for the few FA prospects that hit the market and keep them in an EDR until they are ready so their day to day roster is unaffected. I think this allows the richer teams to maintain a very complete roster and at the same time to have a much better prospect core in their MiLB than they would otherwise have in their EDR.
I challenge you to name a prospect that was "stashed" 3-4 years on an EDR, then went thru the 3- year ARB period as a P-xxxx on the same team. Just isn't realistic here.
@BHows: If it is emulation you guys want, then why not make the 40 man roster a 25 man roster with a 15 MiLB? Also, I read the discussion and I think it was not discussed properly enough as several of the points and implications I touched were not even mentioned. Plus, the rule proposed may have been mentioned exactly like that in the discussion, but very near the end of it. For days you guys were discussing adding a 5 man MiLB. With the implementation, your example is not a good point as the draft occurs after mid-season and the effects of the rule are not seen until the season after. This rule has immediate effects and even affects how FA is handled. It does have major implications on a team's strategy. Finally, regarding the competitiveness, my point is precisely that a good drafter can right now do a good job of rebuilding and he can just promote his rookies when they hit the majors (he has no reason not to). What the MiLB does is basically allow prospect FA signings and prospects obtained in trades in the same roster as draftees (something that occurs way more often than you are making it seem like) and it allows owners to keep these major-league ready prospects stowed away in the minors forever if they never promote them. So basically draft strategy loses importance and trading ability becomes more important. I would say this is a regression for what this league represents.
This rule has been voted on and has passed. With 30 teams some owners will agree and like the change and some won't. This subject has been beaten to death and we need to move on.