0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I have absolutely no intentions of wasting another day arguing about this. I will say that, by definition, a trade only becomes a trade when both parties agree to it. That's why the TC needs confirmation before they vote.
Trade had been agreed to already via PM. Thus, confirmation is only about making sure the public offer is the same as the private one. If this is the way it is going to be then I suggest the rules are rewritten insuch a way that it is clear. Again, I repeat, the rules do not say this anywhere. You guys are making an executive decision regarding whether this was a trade or not and it has resulted in one GM leaving the league. When there is controversy, you might as well put it to a league vote or at least allow debate before making a final ruling. Flexibility is a good thing.