Dallas and Chicago make a swap

[Tarheels55]

After looking at this trade Dallas is clear winner here by a mile

After reading what Pigrule says i clearly agree with his points on this trade

Therefore I

 :veto:

[hockeyfreak47]

ok i feel i have to give some input on this one to say why i approve that deal earlier :judge:

Takes 3 approvals for the trade to be confirmed. same goes for veto's

- Commenting on trades what everyone is not seeing in this deal is that Jonathan Toews missed nearly two months due to a concussion then played 6 playoff games and decided not to go to worlds ... is he a 100%? ... Dallas is willing to take that chance like most of us would but he could end up whit only Biron to show for all he gave up in that trade and for Chicago with that trade he get's extra body to replace some players that need extension :

Jonathan Carlsson  - 0 fp/g        for     Johnny Oduya - 0.65 fp/g
John Scott               - 0.42 fp/g   for     Matt Gilroy - 0.85 fp/g
Tom Kostopoulos     - 0.79 fp/g  for     Danny Cleary RW/LW - 1.54 fp/g
Erik Christensen      - 0.60 fp/g   for    Stephen Weiss  - 1.67 fp/g

by doing this he will be able to re-sign his best player Sharp and Grabner too
+ he gets 3 prospect so his team will be better because of that trade :thumbsup:

- Deciding who won/who lost    Dallas if Toews stays healty  :thumbsup:

- The fairness of the trade both teams get better by doing this trade  :thumbsup:

- Whether the trade was legit or set up  legit  :thumbsup:

- Whether the trade would be a detriment to that franchise or the league.
NO  :thumbsup:

[PigsRule]

thread is unlocked. trade commmite please vote so justice can be completed fairly.

only commissioner's or site admins can unlock threads which have been closed + locked.

member advised + mod access revoked.

thread closed.

it will be left posted on the main transactions board for a few days, then filed in "Invalid Transactions".

 :judge:

thread re-closed.
matter addressed via PM with a larger group.