| DB Antoine Bethea, $0.5m (2013) | $0.5m | $0.5m | | | |
| DB Antonio Cromartie, $0.9m (2012) | $0.9m | | | | |
| DB Brent Grimes, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| DB Cedric Griffin, $3.5m (2013) | $3.5m | $3.5m | | | |
| DB Chris Gamble, $0.3m (2012) | $0.3m | | | | |
| DB DeAngelo Hall, $3.5m (2014) | $3.5m | $3.5m | $3.5m | | |
| DB Jamarca Sanford, $0.3m (2013) | $0.3m | $0.3m | | | |
| DB Keenan Lewis, $0.3m (2013) | $0.3m | $0.3m | | | |
| DB Kurt Coleman, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| DB Quinton Carter, $0.3m (2013) | $0.3m | $0.3m | | | |
| DB Troy Polamalu, $6.5m (2012) | $6.5m | | | | |
| DL Bradon Thompson, $0.5m (2014) | $0.5m | $0.5m | $0.5m | | |
| DL Calais Campbell, $7m (2015) | $7m | $7m | $7m | $7m | |
| DL Jerel Worthy, $0.5m (2014) | $0.5m | $0.5m | $0.5m | | |
| DL Jeremy Mincey, $0.3m (2012) | $0.3m | | | | |
| DL Jerry Hughes, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| DL Randy Starks, $0.4m (2012) | $0.4m | | | | |
| DL Will Smith, $1.5m (2012) | $1.5m | | | | |
| K/P Adam Vinatieri, $0.5m (2013) | $0.5m | $0.5m | | | |
| K/P Connor Barth, $0.3m (2012) | $0.3m | | | | |
| K/P Pat McAfee, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| LB Daryl Sharpton, $0.3m (2013) | $0.3m | $0.3m | | | |
| LB David Harris, $2.1m (2013) | $2.1m | $2.1m | | | |
| LB Erik Walden, $0.3m (2012) | $0.3m | | | | |
| LB James Anderson, $5.5m (2015) | $5.5m | $5.5m | $5.5m | $5.5m | |
| LB K.J. Wright, $0.3m (2012) | $0.3m | | | | |
| LB Kamerion Wimbley, $0.3m (2012) | $0.3m | | | | |
| LB Koa Misi, $0.4m (2013) | $0.4m | $0.4m | | | |
| LB Pat Angerer, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| LB Sam Acho, $4.3m (2013) | $4.3m | $4.3m | | | |
| QB Andrew Luck, $6m (2015) | $6m | $6m | $6m | $6m | |
| QB Chandler Harnish, $0.4m (2015) | $0.4m | $0.4m | $0.4m | $0.4m | |
| QB Drew Stanton, $1.3m (2012) | $1.3m | | | | |
| QB Tavaris Jackson, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| RB Christopher Ivory, $3.5m (2012) | $3.5m | | | | |
| RB Steven Jackson, $7.5m (2013) | $7.5m | $7.5m | | | |
| RB Tim Hightower, $5m (2013) | $5m | $5m | | | |
| RB Willis McGahee, $3m (2014) | $3m | $3m | $3m | | |
| RB-WR Darius Reynaud, $0.3m (2013) | $0.3m | $0.3m | | | |
| TE Anthony McCoy, $0.3m (2013) | $0.3m | $0.3m | | | |
| TE Craig Stevens, $0.5m (2013) | $0.5m | $0.5m | | | |
| TE Jermaine Gresham, $4.5m (2012) | $4.5m | | | | |
| WR Brian Hartline, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| WR Doug Baldwin, $0.5m (2012) | $0.5m | | | | |
| WR Jason Avant, $1m (2014) | $1m | $1m | $1m | | |
| WR Josh Morgan, $1m (2013) | $1m | $1m | | | |
| WR Marques Colston, $5m (2014) | $5m | $5m | $5m | | |
| WR Michael Floyd, $5m (2014) | $5m | $5m | $5m | | |
| WR Pierre Garcon, $5.5m (2015) | $5.5m | $5.5m | $5.5m | $5.5m | |