RHP Aceves, Alfredo, $0.25m (P-2012) (10 points)  | $0.25m | | | | | | |
MI Beckham, Gordon, $0.5m (P-2012) (10 points)  | $0.50m | | | | | | |
| MI Betancourt, Yuniesky, $m (2011) (10 points) FA | | | | | | | |
RHP-S Boggs, Mitchell, $0.5m (P-2012) (10 points)  | $0.50m | | | | | | |
LHP Cecil, Brett, $0.25m (P-2012) (10 points)  | $0.25m | | | | | | |
LF Coghlan, Chris, $0.5m (P-2012) (10 points)  | $0.50m | | | | | | |
| RHP Corpas, Manuel, $m (2011) (10 points) FA | | | | | | | |
MI Ellis, Mark, $5.5m (2013) (10 points)  | $5.50m | $5.50m | | | | | |
| CI Glaus, Troy, $m (2011) (10 points) FA | | | | | | | |
OF Gomes, Johnny, $2m (2013) (10 points)  | $2.00m | $2.00m | | | | | |
LHP-S Gonzalez, Gio, $0.5m (P-2012) (10 points)  | $0.50m | | | | | | |
RHP-S Guthrie, Jeremy, $3m (2013) (10 points)  | $3.00m | $3.00m | | | | | |
RHP-S Hernandez, Felix, $15.5m (2014) (10 points)  | $15.50m | $15.50m | $15.50m | | | | |
OF Heyward, Jason, $0.5m (P-2013) (10 points)  | $0.50m | $0.50m | | | | | |
RHP-S Hudson, Daniel, $0.25m (P-2013) (10 points)  | $0.25m | $0.25m | | | | | |
RHP-S Hudson, Tim, $9.25m (2014) (10 points)  | $9.25m | $4.00m | $4.00m | | | | |
MI Johnson, Kelly, $20m (2015) (10 points)  | $20.00m | $20.00m | $20.00m | $20.00m | | | |
RHP-S Lackey, John, $16.5m (2014) (10 points)  | $16.50m | $16.50m | $16.50m | | | | |
RHP League, Brandon, $2m (2013) (10 points)  | $2.00m | $2.00m | | | | | |
CI Longoria, Evan, $17m (2016) (10 points)  | $17.00m | $17.00m | $17.00m | $17.00m | $17.00m | | |
C Martin, Russell, $4m (2013) (10 points)  | $4.00m | $4.00m | | | | | |
RHP Mota, Guillermo, $0.25m (2012) (10 points)  | $0.25m | | | | | | |
| RHP O'Day, Darren, $m (2011) (10 points) FA | | | | | | | |
OF Pagan, Angel, $5.5m (2012) (10 points)  | $5.50m | | | | | | |
CF Rasmus, Colby, $0.5m (P-2012) (10 points)  | $0.50m | | | | | | |
RF-CF Rios, Alex, $10.75m (2014) (10 points)  | $10.75m | $10.75m | $10.75m | | | | |
MI Roberts, Brian, $10m (2013) (10 points)  | $10.00m | $10.00m | | | | | |
| C Rodriguez, Ivan, $m (2011) (10 points) FA | | | | | | | |
MI Rollins, Jimmy, $6.5m (2014) (10 points)  | $6.50m | $6.50m | $6.50m | | | | |
| CF Sizemore, Grady, $m (2011) (10 points) FA | | | | | | | |
OF Smith, Seth, $6.5m (2015) (10 points)  | $6.50m | $6.50m | $6.50m | $6.50m | | | |
CI Smoak, Justin, $0.25m (P-2013) (10 points)  | $0.25m | $0.25m | | | | | |
CI Stewart, Ian, $3m (2014) (10 points)  | $3.00m | $3.00m | $3.00m | | | | |
CI Teixeira, Mark, $22.5m (2016) (10 points)  | $22.50m | $22.50m | $22.50m | $22.50m | $22.50m | | |
CI-MI Uribe, Juan, $6m (2012) (10 points)  | $6.00m | | | | | | |
LHP Venters, Jonny, $0.25m (P-2013) (10 points)  | $0.25m | $0.25m | | | | | |
RHP-S Volquez, Edinson, $10.5m (2015) (10 points)  | $10.50m | $10.50m | $10.50m | $10.50m | | | |
RHP-S Weaver, Jared, $20m (2015) (10 points)  | $20.00m | $20.00m | $20.00m | $20.00m | | | |
CI Wright, David, $9.25m (2012) (10 points)  | $9.25m | | | | | | |
| RHP Ziegler, Brad, $m (2011) (10 points) FA | | | | | | | |