Author Topic: Revisiting the Posey Play ~ OR ~ Getting the Umpire out of his Comfort Zone!  (Read 553 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline reedjohnson

  • All-Pro
  • ***
  • Join Date: Jan 2011
  • Posts: 1965
  • Bonus inPoints: 0
  • Fantasy Prestige 4
    • :CHC:
    • :Blank:
    • :Blank:
    • :Blank:
    • :Milwaukee:
    • :Blank:
    • :Blank:
    • View Profile
The following is a guest post from Ronni Redmond at Garlicfriesandbaseball. Redmond is a member of the Baseball Blogger's Alliance.



The only reason I’m bringing this up again is because Calcaterra over at Hardball Talk said Posey was told to “stop” blocking the plate.   This implies that Posey “was” blocking the plate, which he was not as the photo above clearly shows.  The runner intentionally left the baseline with a spectacular charge  aimed directly towards the catcher with no intention of getting to the home plate.  The runner, Scott Cousins,  said later his intention was to dislodge the ball~ which he could not, because Buster never had it.

But here’s what’s really amazing about this photo.   Notice the umpire.  No one  had a better birds-eye view than this umpire, standing steadfast and staring intently at the play as it was happening and boom!  Crash!  Bam! Slam!   The play’s over and the umpire calls the runner safe, run counts,  and the catcher is lying mortally wounded* (defined below) on the field.  What the heck was he thinking?  The umpire I mean.

Somehow it seems reasonable that MLB Rule 7.08 (b) could be construed to somehow apply in this situation.  A good attorney could probably make it work.  I don’t know.  I’m just saying the umpire has total charge of the game.   And in this case I  think he let this one get by.  Too bad.  Would have been a real feather in his cap if he’d stepped up to the plate (no pun intended) took a stand and said something like “No more! This ain’t gonna happen on my watch”.   Like the NFL did when they made it illegal to spear with their helmets, with no intentional blows to the head.

Who knows?  An umpire taking a stand.  Might have changed the game forever.  He has the authority to do that you know. Baseball needs a little cleaning up.   It’s not just bulldozing the catcher at the plate that can get really nasty, but what about all those pitches thrown at the batter’s head, back, arm, foot, leg in retaliation for some stupid reason (there are hundreds of them) that everyone knows about, including the umpires.  They all know what’s going on.  It’s extremely rare that a pitcher gets thrown out of a game for hitting or trying to hit a batter, even though it happens regularly.  And if a pitcher does happen to be ejected for intentionally hitting a batter the minimum fine is a whopping $200! (MLB Rule 8.02)  Can you believe it?  Who makes these rules.  I mean a batter could get killed, and has, from one of those bean balls.

You can read the rest of the article here, on Redmond's website.

« Last Edit: February 29, 2012, 11:01:01 AM by reedjohnson »
Dempster–Castro-Reed-Rizzo-Kerry


:Milwaukee: student and :CHC2: fan.

Offline Colby

  • MVP
  • ***
  • Join Date: Jan 2009
  • Posts: 30418
  • Bonus inPoints: 27
  • Fantasy Prestige 57
    • :PIT:
    • :PIT-NFL:
    • :Blank:
    • :PIT-NHL:
    • :PennState:
    • :UnitedStates:
    • :Blank:
    • View Profile
    • Buy me a beer
This has been one of your best articles.  Fantasy owners will appreciate Posey not blocking the plate this season, but as you pointed out, it is clear that he wasn't doing that when his leg was shattered by the bulldozing Scott Cousins.  With injuries being a concern, where would you draft Posey in a 12-team standard 6x6 league?  I am thinking about keeping him in such a league that would make him my 5th keeper (giving him the 50th selection).
Learn about :Commish: inPoints and the Invitationals.

Offline Mr.TradeKing

  • MVP
  • ***
  • Join Date: Apr 2010
  • Posts: 6330
  • Bonus inPoints: 158
  • Fantasy Prestige 9
    • :ATL:
    • :MIA:
    • :MIA-NBA:
    • :WAS-NHL:
    • :SouthCarolina:
    • :ASR:
    • :Blank:
    • View Profile
I didn't think this was a dirty play then or now. First, it was in extra innings and both teams were playing hard for the win. Second, it WAS a "bang, bang" play at home and there is no way possible for Scott Cousins to know that Posey didn't have the ball. In fact, the ball arrives before Cousins, and if Posey catches the ball, Cousins is probably out. Thirdly, Posey WAS trying to apply the tag and was in the basepath. That picture posted with the article is VERY, VERY deceiving. Finally, Cousins was within his right to collide with Posey as that is apart of the game and comes the backstop position. Everytime Posey (or any of other C) suits up, they know that and willingly go out there and play. He had no intentions of injuring Posey (he was just trying to score and win the game), which is evident by his initial reaction after scoring. He actually looked more concerned than Posey's teammate. I believe this video says it all: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUHVImQoQug

I think home plate collisions and pitching throwing at hitters in retaliation are good parts of the game and would hate to see them taken out. We all see how that worked for the NFL....

~MTK
"A champion gets up when he can't." ~ Jack Dempsey



Twitter: MTK_ProFSL

Offline WhiteSoxFan4Life

  • Rookie
  • *
  • Join Date: Mar 2012
  • Posts: 14
  • Bonus inPoints: 0
  • Fantasy Prestige 0
    • :Blank:
    • :Blank:
    • :Blank:
    • :Blank:
    • :Illinois:
    • :Blank:
    • View Profile
I think it's clear that the runner had no intention of hurting Posey and was trying to score.  He didn't know Posey didn't have the ball and was reacting to the play.  To call this a dirty play just doesn't sit right with me.  I'm sorry Posey got hurt but I think you do a great disservice to Cousins by implying he was a dirty player.  Both players were playing the game hard and neither deserves to be villified.

 

Forum Search


Quick Profile

 
 
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

* Chat Room

Refresh History
  • Jonathan: hard to say this, but the Cavs should get rid of Lebron. Kyrie is 7 yrs younger and Lebron can leave after the year anyways.
    Yesterday at 01:58:49 AM
  • Daddy: The pm I got says to move fantraxed items to update on roster.
    Yesterday at 01:59:28 AM
  • indiansnation: daddy to update on roster
    Yesterday at 01:59:51 AM
  • Daddy: Smart move by Kyrie. Cavs owner is not a likable guy and if not for LeBron would have never won.
    Yesterday at 02:00:36 AM
  • indiansnation: man lbj is so upset by what irving said
    Yesterday at 02:00:42 AM
  • Daddy: Remember Anthony Bennett?
    Yesterday at 02:01:01 AM
  • indiansnation: he just basicly said he hates playing with lbj
    Yesterday at 02:01:09 AM
  • Daddy: My daughter plays better than him too.
    Yesterday at 02:01:20 AM
  • indiansnation: yes
    Yesterday at 02:01:21 AM
  • indiansnation: my 101 yr old grandma can play better than him
    Yesterday at 02:02:01 AM
  • Daddy: Kyrie should go and LeBron is already gone after next year. Sorry Brian.
    Yesterday at 02:02:07 AM
  • indiansnation: if she was still alive
    Yesterday at 02:02:14 AM
  • indiansnation: man i dont know talking 3 way trade involving  knicks,cavs and phoneix with anthony coming to cleveland
    Yesterday at 02:03:20 AM
  • Daddy: Good luck with that
    Yesterday at 02:04:27 AM
  • Jonathan: We can have a 2003 draft party again lol
    Yesterday at 02:04:59 AM
  • indiansnation: anthony and bledsoe and 2018 first rd pick irving going to knicks shump going to phoneix
    Yesterday at 02:05:24 AM
  • Jonathan: Irving value is much more than Anthony.
    Yesterday at 02:05:44 AM
  • Daddy: You gonna type up another apology after you cussed the league for a second straight day? LOL
    Yesterday at 02:05:54 AM
  • indiansnation: no matter what irving going to a team he pissed off the rest of the guys on cavs
    Yesterday at 02:06:21 AM
  • Daddy: Called my man Ryan everything but a son of God :)
    Yesterday at 02:06:28 AM
  • indiansnation: who me i didnt swear this time. i just confrunted it all
    Yesterday at 02:07:04 AM
  • Daddy: You gotta be a goid man to wear Cleveland on your sleeves.
    Yesterday at 02:07:18 AM
  • indiansnation: daddy i lie
    Yesterday at 02:07:24 AM
  • Daddy: Good man*
    Yesterday at 02:07:30 AM
  • Daddy: Its worse than being a Philly fan, rooting for Cleveland sports.
    Yesterday at 02:08:05 AM
  • indiansnation: daddy lets not start this up again
    Yesterday at 02:08:13 AM
  • indiansnation: daddy not cool lol
    Yesterday at 02:08:35 AM
  • Daddy: We threw a parade for arena football in Philly
    Yesterday at 02:08:51 AM
  • indiansnation: my cavs one on
    Yesterday at 02:08:51 AM
  • indiansnation: won one probably be the last but they one a championship
    Yesterday at 02:09:16 AM
  • Daddy: And a BooYah! horse named Smarty Jones
    Yesterday at 02:09:32 AM
  • indiansnation: thats all that matters
    Yesterday at 02:09:33 AM
  • Jonathan: They won their 1. Looking like its the Indians/ BJ's  with best shot going forward.
    Yesterday at 02:09:48 AM
  • Daddy: Smarty didn't even win the triple crown. We celebrated 2/3 of it.
    Yesterday at 02:10:19 AM
  • indiansnation: what does smarty jones got to do with anything man im lost lol
    Yesterday at 02:10:39 AM
  • Daddy: That's how bad Philly/Cleveland sports have been.
    Yesterday at 02:11:16 AM
  • indiansnation: ok i dont think a player should have any say who the gm gets. isi
    Yesterday at 02:11:21 AM
  • Daddy: When you parading a horse...you starving for a winner man.
    Yesterday at 02:11:52 AM
  • indiansnation: it his money right know cavs owner has to pay 80m in cap hits for over spending thats crazy
    Yesterday at 02:12:04 AM
  • indiansnation: ok johnathan and daddy if u were the owner of cavs would u just give away 80m to just please a nba player
    Yesterday at 02:13:22 AM
  • indiansnation: her is how bad it is if cavs use ther 2.1 mid level it will cost cavs owner 21m in cap fine
    Yesterday at 02:14:33 AM
  • Jonathan: Houston hasn't won anything since
    Yesterday at 02:17:29 AM
  • Jonathan: the dream was around 94-95
    Yesterday at 02:17:45 AM
  • Jonathan: MLB team never won or Football teams.
    Yesterday at 02:18:22 AM
  • indiansnation: lds pm
    Yesterday at 02:18:34 AM
  • Jonathan: They do have a few MLS titles, but that doesn't count lol
    Yesterday at 02:18:58 AM
  • Jonathan: Astros have a chance to break that 20 + years drought.
    Yesterday at 02:20:04 AM
  • indiansnation: daddy pm
    Yesterday at 02:35:56 AM
  • indiansnation: see u guys soon im off for know lost my fun being on here today. good lucj wuth your team daddy
    Yesterday at 02:51:24 AM
  • indiansnation: probably be back on in  weak or so
    Yesterday at 02:57:37 AM