MLB Prospect Rankings - P - Pitchers

C | CI | MI | OF | P

Last updated: December 14, 2012

Prospect rankings below are compiled several times per year.  The goal of these rankings is to show how we at ProFSL think that these players will perform in most fantasy leagues over their careers.

1) Trevor Bauer :ARZ: - Bauer strikes out more than one batter per inning
2) Dylan Bundy :BAL: - Part of Baltimore success story in 2012
3) Shelby Miller :STL: - Will be 2013 mainstay in St. Louis
4) Jameson Taillon :PIT: - Tracked to be fixture in Pirates 2014 rotation
5) Danny Hultzen :SEA: - Needs to improve upon AAA showing in 2012
6) Gerrit Cole :PIT: - Cole, part of the Pirates' two aces in their farm system actually picked up some AAA experience in his first year
7) Julio Teheran :ATL: - Rated as top five overall prospect by Baseball America 2011-12
8) Tyler Skaggs :ARZ: - His time (four seasons) in the minors is enough; it's time for the show (should be regular starter by 2014)
9) Taijuan Walker :SEA: - Like the Pirates, the Mariners have two aces stashed in the minors
10) Martin Perez :TEX: - Rated top 31 prospect or better from 2010-12 by Baseball America, but AAA WHIP over past two seasons is just a 1.50
11) A.J. Cole :OAK:
12) Mike Montgomery :KC:
13) Carlos Martinez :STL:
14) Zach Wheeler :NYM:
15) Jake Odorizzi :KC:
16) Archie Bradley :ARZ:
17) James Paxton :SEA: - Hultzen, Walker, and Paxton are giving Seattle a lot of hope
18) Chris Archer :TB:
19) Trevor May :PHI:
20) Jose Fernandez :MIA-MLB:
21) Manny Banuelos :NYY:
22) Daniel Straily :OAK: - We had a nice glance at his stuff in the majors in 2012
23) Jarred Cosart :HOU: - Top 50 spec by BA pre-2012
24) Zach Lee :LAD:
25) Brad Peacock :OAK:
26) Robbie Erlin :SD: - Sported a sub 1.01 WHIP in 326.1 innings from 2009-12 in MILB
27) Casey Kelly :SD:
28) Taylor Jungmann :MIL:
29) Sonny Gray :OAK: - Another Oakland A pitcher to sneak into stardom sooner than later
30) Matt Purke :WAS:
31) Tony Cingrani :CIN:
32) Dellin Betances :NYY:
33) Matt Barnes :BOS:
34) Cody Buckel :TEX:
35) Chris Withrow :LAD:
36) Noah Syndergaard :TOR:
37) Lucas Giolito :WAS:
38) Tyrell Jenkins :STL:
39) Jed Bradley :MIL:
40) Stetson Allie :PIT:
41) Casey Crosby :DET:
42) Joe Wieland :SD:
43) Allen Webster :BOS:
44) Max Fried :SD:
45) Hector Santiago :CHW:
46) Kyle Zimmer :KC:
47) Dillon Howard :CLE:
48) Chris Stratton :SF:
49) Deck McGuire :TOR:
50) Andrew Heaney :MIA-MLB:
51) Alex Meyer :WAS:
52) Nick Travieso :CIN:
53) Lucas Sims :ATL:
54) Nick Hagadone :CLE:
55) Kyle Gibson :MIN:
56) Wily Peralta :MIL:
57) Dan Norris :TOR:
58) Taylor Guerrieri :TB:
59) Pierce Johnson :CHC:
60) Jennry Mejia :NYM:
61) Trey McNutt :CHC:
62) Anthony Ranaudo :BOS:
63) Nestor Molina :CHW:
64) Tyler Thornburg :MIL:
65) Chad Bettis :COL:
66) Kevin Gausman :BAL:
67) Alex Torres :TB:
68) Daniel Corcino :CIN:
69) Heath Hembree :SF:
70) Neil Ramirez :TEX:
71) Dan Klein :BAL:
72) Asher Wojciechowski :HOU:
73) Jesse Biddle :PHI:
74) Sean Gilmartin :ATL:
75) Eduardo Sanchez :STL:
76) Brody Colvin :PHI:
77) Luis Heredia :PIT:
78) Jake Sisco :CLE:
79) Jonathan Pettibone :PHI:
80) John Lamb :KC:
81) Jeurys Familia :NYM:
82) Marcus Stroman :TOR:
83) Chad James :MIA-MLB:
84) Aaron Sanchez :TOR:
85) Tanner Scheppers :TEX:
86) Ty Hensley :NYY:
87) Jose Campos :NYY:
88) Joe Ross :SD:
89) Michael Wacha :STL:
90) Phillippe Aumont :PHI:
91) Sammy Solis :WAS:
92) John Hellweg :MIL:
93) Jeff Locke :PIT:
94) Brett Oberholtzer :HOU:
95) Adonys Cardona :TOR:
96) Kyle Crick :SF:
97) Chris Reed :LAD:
98) Jordan Swagerty :STL:
99) David Holmberg :ARZ:
100) Justin Nicolino :TOR:
101) Pat Light :BOS:
102) Alex Colome :TB:
103) Gerardo Concepcion :CHC:
104) Chen-Change Lee :CLE:
105) Elvis Araujo :CLE:
106) Kyle Weiland :HOU:
107) Bruce Rendon :DET:
108) Christopher Brian Johnson :BOS:
109) Lance McCullers :HOU:
110) Alex Burgos :DET:
111) Rob Rasmussen :HOU:
112) Brad Boxberger :SD:
113) Victor Black :PIT:
114) Keyvius Sampson :SD:
115) Dillon Maples :CHC:
116) Walker Weickel :SD:
117) Jose Cisnero :HOU:
118) Yordano Ventura :KC:
119) Justin Grimm :TEX:
120) Robert Stephenson :CIN:
121) Luke Bard :MIN:
122) Raul Alcantara :OAK:
123) Andrew Chafin :ARZ:
124) Colin Wiles :TEX:
125) Jose Berrios :MIN:
126) Eddie Butler :COL:

Share ProFSL on Social Media

ProFSL Fantasy Sports

Chat Room

Refresh History
  • Daddy: its waaaay off Andy
    Yesterday at 11:14:32 PM
  • Daddy: jojo is still new to this, i told him to compthe two and send you guys the errors
    Yesterday at 11:15:33 PM
  • Daddy: he says he sent it to Corey but Corey has been offline and unresponsive
    Yesterday at 11:16:17 PM
  • Daddy: Astros fantrax is current with the exception of the now archived trades
    Yesterday at 11:17:46 PM
  • Anelson: I'll have to look over it tomorrow when I am in front iof a computer.
    Yesterday at 11:19:34 PM
  • Anelson: It will all work out.
    Yesterday at 11:20:28 PM
  • Daddy: Jojo has made a ton of moves since taking over. i explained that these things happen but trying to explain this to a 60 year old is almost futile. All of his transactions were correctly posted, but profsl page is really screwed.
    Yesterday at 11:21:14 PM
  • Daddy: Any help is appreciated. Thanks
    Yesterday at 11:21:41 PM
  • Sportsnut: Hey, watch the remarks about 60 year olds!  :judge:
    Yesterday at 11:22:00 PM
  • nedsports: Tikka is the bomb G
    Yesterday at 11:22:22 PM
  • Daddy: lol
    Yesterday at 11:22:28 PM
  • nedsports: *Tuukka
    Yesterday at 11:22:46 PM
  • Daddy: Sorry Chucky :)
    Yesterday at 11:23:04 PM
  • nedsports: iPad spellcheck is a joke lol
    Yesterday at 11:24:25 PM
  • Sportsnut: So, is jojo you dad?  :rofl:
    Yesterday at 11:24:29 PM
  • Fourfingerwoo: poppa doc,keeping it real for the blue hairs
    Yesterday at 11:24:55 PM
  • Daddy: You baby boomers can be a lil sensitive over computers etc. My dad cusses his cpu throughout the day
    Yesterday at 11:25:41 PM
  • Sportsnut: that's Q-tips, sonny!
    Yesterday at 11:26:06 PM
  • Sportsnut: I've been working with computers probably before you were born
    Yesterday at 11:26:37 PM
  • Daddy: You should trade me Davis. You told me to kick rocks before i even pressed send.
    Yesterday at 11:27:54 PM
  • Daddy: If i can tell you the name of the first ever cpu, we make the trade Dick?
    Yesterday at 11:29:18 PM
  • Daddy: The Eniac :) you work on it?
    Yesterday at 11:30:13 PM
  • Sportsnut: Not true on Davis.  I said don't waste your time hitting the 'send message' button.  lol
    Yesterday at 11:31:08 PM
  • Sportsnut: No, the first was the abacus!  I invented it!
    Yesterday at 11:31:38 PM
  • Daddy: lol
    Yesterday at 11:33:40 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: actually the first computer can't be verified
    Yesterday at 11:35:02 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: although the abacus is commonly referred to as the 1st computer
    Yesterday at 11:35:27 PM
  • Sportsnut: that's right, Aubrrey.
    Yesterday at 11:39:06 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: anyone know the code for AS Roma?
    Yesterday at 11:40:41 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: :ASR:
    Yesterday at 11:40:55 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: dumb luck
    Yesterday at 11:41:00 PM
  • nedsports: Red Sox 30-20 start is the best since 2008, we just need a power hitter and we will be a playoff team
    Yesterday at 11:43:17 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: replied Eric
    Yesterday at 11:45:42 PM
  • nedsports: Why was the abacus around for thousands of years and the computer only 40 years? Weird??
    Yesterday at 11:46:06 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: Mariner, you around?
    Yesterday at 11:46:12 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: limited by technology
    Yesterday at 11:46:32 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: thats a BIG jump
    Yesterday at 11:46:47 PM
  • fantasyguru: MTK
    Yesterday at 11:47:11 PM
  • Sportsnut: Amazingly, the first computers had less capability that a basic computer chip today.
    Yesterday at 11:48:06 PM
  • Mr.TradeKing: what's good Reid?
    Yesterday at 11:49:06 PM
  • nedsports: Everything is better today except for Justin Bieber, please take him back Canada!
    Yesterday at 11:58:23 PM
  • nedsports: I never get sick of Deadliest Catch drama, lol
    Yesterday at 11:59:49 PM
  • fantasyguru: want to trade
    Today at 12:00:42 AM
  • nedsports: Hey guru
    Today at 12:03:02 AM
  • Tony: No thanks, we don't want Justin back. lol
    Today at 12:03:55 AM
  • Mr.TradeKing: sure what league Reid? Bush?
    Today at 12:12:22 AM
  • 9inches: any trade ideas for MB :CIN:?
    Today at 12:13:14 AM
  • nedsports: Im looking for future MTK NFL trades, looking to move Suh for a CB I have to Manley DL
    Today at 12:16:12 AM
  • nedsports: *many
    Today at 12:17:26 AM
  • nedsports: *FMK
    Today at 12:17:57 AM