Home
Staff
View the memberlist
Search For Members
Portal
Mentions
League Openings
League Search
Login
Register
Leagues
ProFSL: Pro Fantasy Sports Leagues
»
Fantasy Leagues
»
MLB Leagues
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball: Archives
(Moderators:
indiansnation
,
Vik
,
EastCoastGonzo
) »
Internal or External Trade Committee?
« previous
next »
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Down
Author
Topic: Internal or External Trade Committee? (Read 1007 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
kenny
MVP
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2653
Bonus inPoints: 1
Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
on:
June 29, 2011, 11:34:12 PM »
I see other leagues have discussed the possibility of utilizing a trade committee utilizing outside members (the ProFSL TC or PTC). See this thread for Franchise GM League's discussion of this topic:
http://www.profsl.com/smf/index.php?topic=24345.0
I have mixed feelings on this as both options have their pros and cons. Letting outside members vote on trades may eliminate the possibility of biases, but they may also not know the real value of a player in this league. Yes, they are supposed to be well-versed in each leagues rules, but how effective can that really be without participating in it (in a league with custom rules)?
While I do have my opinions, this is definitely open for discussion and I'm open-minded.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Orange Country
Legend
Join Date: May 2011
Posts: 14334
Bonus inPoints: 1281
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #1 on:
June 30, 2011, 01:32:56 AM »
Since Shelby wants to help you out Kenny, ask his opinion as well. In my opinion, the PROFSL TC can be an asset to our league and I would endorse it as it is the best people picked by Colby himself. Now, this would eliminate Dave, me, and whomever else serves on it when the league opens soon. The trade committee is also responsible for making sure each move is legal within cap and roster parameters so we would still have a role, just not as big of one. Yes, we would know the rules the best, but there are some vets in PROFSL that really can look at a trade with a bit more experienced eyes and gauge a bit better with having the rules in mind.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Corey
Guest
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #2 on:
June 30, 2011, 02:03:40 AM »
I vote external
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
hank
All-Star
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 1019
Bonus inPoints: 0
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #3 on:
June 30, 2011, 02:26:17 AM »
External.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
There are lies, there are outrageous lies, and there are statistics.
---
Mark Twain
molinator
MVP
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 4085
Bonus inPoints: 0
:RMA:
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #4 on:
June 30, 2011, 09:15:02 AM »
External
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
sdobelman21
Guest
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #5 on:
June 30, 2011, 05:08:42 PM »
Wouldn't an external TC be a little bit of a burden on the members of the TC. I'm sure that the people on that TC already have enough things to do given their responsibilities on the website. I would just hate for people to be burdened with a league the are not affiliated with, because I know I really wouldn't want to be responsible for a league I wasn't involved in.
I'm fine either way just wanted to throw my 2 cents out there.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
kenny
MVP
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 2653
Bonus inPoints: 1
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #6 on:
June 30, 2011, 06:52:10 PM »
The external TC is comprised of volunteers and do not necessarily have other responsibilities on this website. They already know this is for other leagues.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Shelby
MVP
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 4114
Bonus inPoints: 0
:NYJL:
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #7 on:
June 30, 2011, 06:54:29 PM »
With an external TC, no problems with a trade approved by the TC while that is unfair. no member may say that the one who vetoed protect its interests ... etc.
As noted above, the members of Profsl TC doesn't know the rules and the value of players in this league, what is true and can be a big problem but I saw that Corey and Fantasyguru were interested in joining Profsl the TC. If two members of the league are part of Profsl TC, we can count on them to explain, underline, remember the rules and values of the players.
I vote external TC
«
Last Edit: July 01, 2011, 06:56:34 AM by Shelby
»
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
mcmccullough
Guest
Re: Internal or External Trade Committee?
«
Reply #8 on:
July 01, 2011, 02:19:55 AM »
I would vote external. I feel that eliminates bias, and I'm the type who thinks a veto is only used if the trade can be harmful to the integrity of the league, and I don't feel an external TC has to have the in-depth knowledge necessarily to know whether a trade can hurt the league's integrity as a whole.
Logged
0
0
0
No reactions
No reactions
No reactions
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Up
« previous
next »
ProFSL: Pro Fantasy Sports Leagues
»
Fantasy Leagues
»
MLB Leagues
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball
»
Armchair Fantasy Baseball: Archives
(Moderators:
indiansnation
,
Vik
,
EastCoastGonzo
) »
Internal or External Trade Committee?
Forum Search
Quick Profile
Username:
Password:
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Did you miss your
activation email
?
Chat Room
STLBlues91
:
Yeah got to figure a solid name out for it
Yesterday
at 11:55:35 PM
Daddy
:
Had a few good suggestions. Just dont be corny.. this represents all of us.
Yesterday
at 11:57:03 PM
Daddy
:
We are the first to give Vegas a suggestion. Lets let it be a good one. Make them take notice.
Yesterday
at 11:57:48 PM
STLBlues91
:
Yeah will research it a bit
Yesterday
at 11:57:58 PM
Daddy
:
One of the NHL signup sheets has 68k views? Thats ridiculous. Where all these people at? We should have 20k leagues.
Today
at 12:00:38 AM
Rhino7
:
I used to use Las Vegas Vipers as a team name
Today
at 12:04:13 AM
Daddy
:
NHL & NCAA have 100k views on the bullpen. Nobody ever looked at that thing. There should be a few more new accounts no? I mean what they looking for. Its a sign up sheet.
Today
at 12:04:17 AM
Daddy
:
Vipers works for me if it does you. Kinda goes with the logo i gave them.
Today
at 12:05:04 AM
STLBlues91
:
Yeah writing down the names sent out and adding a few I find/think of like Las Vegas Legacy and then will narrow them down
Today
at 12:06:47 AM
RyanJames5
:
Can I take the Sonics?
Today
at 12:07:14 AM
Brent
:
Vipers is cool.
Today
at 12:08:08 AM
Daddy
:
Yes sir
Today
at 12:08:19 AM
Daddy
:
I will tentatively put the Vipers until we launch fantrax
Today
at 12:08:59 AM
RyanJames5
:
Very fun idea to expand.
Today
at 12:09:36 AM
Daddy
:
Indeed sir, indeed. What College RJ?
Today
at 12:10:11 AM
RyanJames5
:
Gonzaga
Today
at 12:13:00 AM
Daddy
:
Roger that Zags
Today
at 12:14:13 AM
BayAreaBallers
:
im excited for this a properly run nba dynasty from scratch
Today
at 12:15:51 AM
RyanJames5
:
Thank you sir
Today
at 12:15:59 AM
BayAreaBallers
:
this is my first LIVE that i sstarted from beginning and didnt take over
Today
at 12:16:16 AM
BayAreaBallers
:
NHL and NBA excited to start those from scratch
Today
at 12:16:59 AM
Daddy
:
All the leagues are well run, we just have different ideas.
Today
at 12:17:35 AM
Daddy
:
There is nothing like virgin teams that nobody else has been into. You get to inherit todays rosters. Then take them into the future.
Today
at 12:18:36 AM
Daddy
:
Usually taking over a team is inheriting someones mess which is why it was open. In startup leagues that isnt an issue.
Today
at 12:19:25 AM
Daddy
:
I forgot to text Brian.
Today
at 12:21:02 AM
Daddy
:
NBA LIVE Pre-Reserve sign up sheet
[link]
updated!
Today
at 02:31:32 AM
Daddy
:
I grew up watching The Rainman & The Glove. Welcome back to the NBA Seattle Supersonics. Ive missed ya.
Today
at 12:37:30 PM
OUDAN
:
Frick em, They are much better off in OKC
Today
at 12:54:01 PM
Daddy
:
Thats cold
Today
at 01:03:25 PM
Daddy
:
I should have known you jumped off the Lakers and on to the home state squad. We havent talked basketball much here like the old days.
Today
at 01:08:21 PM
Daddy
:
When Philly drafted Embiid that year we had LOR (Lord of the Rings) and we talked much hoops.
Today
at 01:10:18 PM
OUDAN
:
I refused before because of KD but this squad you cant help but love the way they play
Today
at 01:17:16 PM
OUDAN
:
Also I swear I enjoy fantasy basketball more than any other.
Today
at 01:20:09 PM
Daddy
:
Well you are Oklahoma Dan. Makes sense for you to love OKC & OU. Fricking Boomer Sooner!!!
Today
at 01:35:12 PM
OUDAN
:
Truth
Today
at 02:00:20 PM
Daddy
:
You are also top 5 in my All Time Greatest Fantasy GM ranking. We go back 14 years. If there is a Mount Rushmore for dynasty GMs. You Qualify.
Today
at 02:05:44 PM
Daddy
:
Thats also Truth. Ive seen them all.
Today
at 02:06:08 PM
OUDAN
:
Appreciate that man, Crazy how long some of us have been around here.
Today
at 02:15:49 PM
OUDAN
:
Crazy how long some of us have been on here
Today
at 02:15:58 PM
Daddy
:
I was hooked right away. Day 1 Scouting Department Baseball Milwaukee Brewers. Its like i was bit by a Vampire.
Today
at 02:26:34 PM
OUDAN
:
I miss when I cared enough about baseball to put the time in lol
Today
at 02:29:23 PM
Daddy
:
Fourteen years of learning. Ive seen leagues and sites fail and shutdown. Ive watched all the sites. All the leagues. People love to play for a buck.
Today
at 02:33:42 PM
OUDAN
:
I for sure prefer money leagues but yeah a lot have failed
Today
at 02:36:12 PM
Daddy
:
Nobody offered what i wanted. Just parts of it. Nobody did it completely right. They copied flawed concepts and theyve failed. 95% of all dynasty leagues fail.
Today
at 02:36:15 PM
Rhino7
:
OUDAN if you want OKC let me know, I’ll take a diff team. I’d like to compete against you more
Today
at 03:12:12 PM
OUDAN
:
Im in if thats an option
Today
at 04:00:45 PM
Rhino7
:
I’ll take Orlando if it’s not an issue
Today
at 04:08:55 PM
OUDAN
:
That would have been my 2nd choice
Today
at 04:15:52 PM
OUDAN
:
Thanks man for that swap
Today
at 04:16:52 PM
Daddy
:
I will make it so
Today
at 05:00:42 PM