0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Guys,We might want to consider revising the scoring for pitchers if we want this league to accurately reflect the pitcher's relative worths in real life. Having a system that doesn't seem to penalize earned runs or baserunners allowed seems to be counter to real life. For example, Justin Masterson is the 23rd ranked pitcher according in fantrax and here are his real life numbers:ERA 5.31WHIP 1.629The only things he seems to do well is produce groundballs and prevent home runs. He is one example, but there are many others. I know people have traded based on the current system, but that should not prevent us from trying to revise it if we agree that it's not realistic.Roy
Maybe I'm missing something. We have 4 pitching categories:GBHR allowedKBBHow exactly are all those fancy stats such as BABIP and FIP taken into account that would measure a pitcher's true ability if we're not using basic ones such as ERA and WHIP? Absent that, perhaps someone who came up with this measure could explain how it's superior to the ones used in the major leagues in salary talks. I'm not trying to reinvent the wheel here, but I've seen horrible games by pitchers who have allowed 10, 11 hits and 8-10 ER (such as recent games by Shields and Maholm) result in average pitching points because of the stats we're using. I'd like to hear from the rest of the RC on this issue.