0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
I'm not on the TC (and don't want to be) so I'm free to plug my opinion here without too much thought. Personally I think Gilly is overpaying. I'm comparing this back to my Rinne deal (that everyone approved). At the time Rinne was a clear #1 elite starter and I got 2 decent roster players along with a 1st and a 2nd.I'm not saying this isn't what Gilly needs....I like that it's Enroth and he already has Hackett. So clearly this is a good piece for him to acquire. That said I'd like to see one of the 1st round picks removed from the cost.
I don't like the deal because of what Tyler gave up to acquire Enroth before and because of his current situation. He didn't give up much to acquire Enroth because of the fact that he is a back up. So why should Tyler acquire an entire farm now? It doesn't make sense me to right now.If this deal was for Bob or Quick, I would approve. But it is for a back up and a pretty good dman (I don't consider Bogo a stud yet). I
Completely understand the sentiment here, but don;t think a deal should be based on what I paid for a guy before the season started. If that were the case a lot of deals would have to be looked at witha fine tooth comb.