ProFSL: Pro Fantasy Sports Leagues
Fantasy Leagues => Franchise NHL: Transactions => Franchise NHL => NHL Leagues => Franchise NHL: Invalid Transactions => Topic started by: the swede on July 11, 2011, 03:54:04 AM
-
MIN Get:
Carey Price, $5.9m (2013-2014)
MON Get:
2011 1st Round Pick
Josh Harding, $1.0m (2011-2012)
Dan Boyle, $6.7m (2013-2014)
-
I hate commenting when I am not in the TC but wow this hurts the Montreal franchise a lot I would say this is a detriment to the franchise but thats just my opinion
-
Why?
-
Confirmed. Instead of going through free agency I felt acquiring a value through trade would be best. Boyle is in the top 20 in slender and if harding can stay healthy can challenge to be a starter as backstrom is getting old. 1st is low and added to even out trade. Good to see price in a wild uniform.
-
:iatp: Wild win this one.
-
I dont like this trade, i feel montreal is not getting ample reward to there trade. i know im only one tc member but i vote no
-
Nay...Goalies are a prize in this league and Price is way way more valuable than a bucket of rusty nails. 400+ points last season...
-
I'm the 4th no. Price to valuable to the franchise considering the shape it's in..... Harding has had nothing but problems the last 2 years and is parked behind backstrom. The first round pick is a second almost and boyle is getting older and his role is going to be less with the arrival of burns.
-
We will try re-work this trade. What could I give more? We were thinking about adding Latendresse as well. What should we do?
-
We will try re-work this trade. What could I give more? We were thinking about adding Latendresse as well. What should we do?
I think for Price you would need to give up 1st line talent, at least. Its 400 points of production a year...your best lineman gives only 200+. I dunno, how you work it but I know this last one wasn't enough for me.
-
We will try re-work this trade. What could I give more? We were thinking about adding Latendresse as well. What should we do?
I hate this but come on Drew Look at what I had to give to get Price and you still said it wasn't enough and I gave way more then this.
http://www.profsl.com/smf/index.php?topic=22261.0
-
I hate this but come on Drew Look at what I had to give to get Price and you still said it wasn't enough and I gave way more then this.
http://www.profsl.com/smf/index.php?topic=22261.0
Looks like Brouwer, Pronger and some junk to me too. lol
-
Looks like Brouwer, Pronger and some junk to me too. lol
remember at the time he only had 10 players it filled out his roster. I think my offer was 100 times better then a backup a late 1st round pick and a Dman that is going to retire next year
-
remember at the time he only had 10 players it filled out his roster. I think my offer was 100 times better then a backup a late 1st round pick and a Dman that is going to retire next year
:iatp: It leaves Montreal a Huge hole with no real compensation. If they're looking to rebuild I would suggest they get great prospects and picks. But serious NHL talent deserves serious compensation. Otherwise I suggest he field offers for Price and offer him to everyone. I never heard he was available...but I could have missed it as well. Certainly market value would push his price up if others submitted offers for Price.
-
:iatp: It leaves Montreal a Huge hole with no real compensation. If they're looking to rebuild I would suggest they get great prospects and picks. But serious NHL talent deserves serious compensation. Otherwise I suggest he field offers for Price and offer him to everyone. I never heard he was available...but I could have missed it as well. Certainly market value would push his price up if others submitted offers for Price.
:iatp:
If Price is on the Market I will give a huge offer for him as it will set Florida up nicely in net
-
:iatp:
If Price is on the Market I will give a huge offer for him as it will set Florida up nicely in net
Im listening...
-
I hate this but come on Drew Look at what I had to give to get Price and you still said it wasn't enough and I gave way more then this.
http://www.profsl.com/smf/index.php?topic=22261.0
Don't get me started on that trade.
-
Talk about getting screwed over hard. Two members of the trade committee seem to have voted against this trade as they want a shot at Price.
-
remember at the time he only had 10 players it filled out his roster. I think my offer was 100 times better then a backup a late 1st round pick and a Dman that is going to retire next year
Yes, but this was when free agency was open and Montreal could have picked up most of those players by bidding. I don't understand why the GM did not do so. He basically could have got most of those players and keep Price. So you got him for nothing really. It was a good pick up for you. You also got Cammy in the trade. :thumbsup:
-
I dont know how I got put on the TC I didnt want to be on it just couldnt help from not posting my disapproval after I gave more for the same guy
-
I dont know how I got put on the TC I didnt want to be on it just couldnt help from not posting my disapproval after I gave more for the same guy
Yes I could do the same as you and go out and sign a bunch of free agents and then send him for Price but that is bush league. How about you just don't talk about that trade anymore.
-
Talk about getting screwed over hard. Two members of the trade committee seem to have voted against this trade as they want a shot at Price.
Nice try Drew...but I disapproved of the trade from the beginning, so I proposed that you should rework, you argued more and to prove my point I suggested that he field other offers. I am definitely making one...it's not unethical. It wasn't my intent for veto from the get go, and I couldn't veto it by myself either...so stop crying foul play.
-
Nice try Drew...but I disapproved of the trade from the beginning, so I proposed that you should rework, you argued more and to prove my point I suggested that he field other offers. I am definitely making one...it's not unethical. It wasn't my intent for veto from the get go, and I couldn't veto it by myself either...so stop crying foul play.
If you look up into the chat I did say I would re-work. I came back here to see what was being said as it seemed theswede's mind had completely changed on the whole subject. I never said you didn't dissapprove the trade but coming out and saying theswede should start taking offers on Price instead of dealing with me because you and others didn't know he was available isn't the way a trade committee member should present himself on a trade.
BTW never once have I argued the trade in question, I have commented on Jesse's comments about a completely different trade but never made an argument on the trade.
-
I think this trade should be reworked as well. Goalies in this scoring system are at a premium.
-
in the other league price deal i was new and dumb and made a stupid trade that really could of crippled me. which is what im trying to do for habs owner in here. for price u need to command a starting goalie in return at least
-
I think this trade should be reworked as well. Goalies in this scoring system are at a premium.
I would love to re-work but he won't talk to me anymore for some reason. swede if you want to talk to me PM me. My final offer on Price is
Boyle
Harding
Latendresse
1st, 2nd, & 4th round picks.
-
Again my answer is "no" to this trade. It was close as was the previous, but Price needs a bit more to make this trade approvalable from me.
This is not the type of league were having here. This will stop now!!
Again all involved in this in any form will recieve private messages and I will require acknowledgement that you've read the message.
Thanks,
Gilly
-
Wow this got heated. Whats happening here is Crazy!! It will stop and everybody involved has been warned as per Gillys PM. Keep it friendly, remember this is for fun!! I appoligize to you Theswede this is not normal for our league and I hope you don't let it give you a bad impression.
Thanks Gilly for getting things under control.