Blues-Hurricanes Trade

[Godzilla]

I will preface this by saying each owner builds their own way.

I already approved this but in light of some thinking Halo shared I would definitely say this is a type situation given C's are easily found in FNHL and the caliber of scoring wingers the new St Louis owner dealt away is way more value and productive than Nico will ever be in several lifetimes.

[halo99]

I will preface this by saying each owner builds their own way.

I already approved this but in light of some thinking Halo shared I would definitely say this is a type situation given C's are easily found in FNHL and the caliber of scoring wingers the new St Louis owner dealt away is way more value and productive than Nico will ever be in several lifetimes.

Godzilla this is quite a bit different than the trade I vetoed. Go look at all the trades and involving 30 year old back up goalies and tell me where one brought a scoring forward, a number 6 pick in the draft and a top Goalie prospect in return.

Nico was the first overall pick just two years ago and has enormous upside. He was traded for a 33 year old winger who played great last year, but his age limits his value in a dynasty league. We also got 1.5 ppg player who's making 4.2m a year as the offsetting pieces of the trade. Those two trades are apples and oranges. I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings vetoing your friends trade but I am looking at the trades that go on and have every right to voice my opinion on something that seems a little off. 

[Godzilla]

Godzilla this is quite a bit different than the trade I vetoed. Go look at all the trades and involving 30 year old back up goalies and tell me where one brought a scoring forward, a number 6 pick in the draft and a top Goalie prospect in return.

Nico was the first overall pick just two years ago and has enormous upside. He was traded for a 33 year old winger who played great last year, but his age limits his value in a dynasty league. We also got 1.5 ppg player who's making 4.2m a year as the offsetting pieces of the trade. Those two trades are apples and oranges. I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings vetoing your friends trade but I am looking at the trades that go on and have every right to voice my opinion on something that seems a little off.

I still approve this deal. Saying Nico was 1st is like so what, weak draft class. Ducks owner isnt a friend but I felt the Halo and AntMan tag team didnt sound right.

Kind of makes me think you guys were trying to sell some other backup that Anh or StL didnt want and now there's bad mouthing. Seen it before that's all.

[halo99]

I still approve this deal. Saying Nico was 1st is like so what, weak draft class. Ducks owner isnt a friend but I felt the Halo and AntMan tag team didnt sound right.

Kind of makes me think you guys were trying to sell some other backup that Anh or StL didnt want and now there's bad mouthing. Seen it before that's all.

I know End Game isn't your friend because a friend wouldn't let another friend do a deal like that 

You have every right to veto if you feel something is crazy lopsided or doesn't make sense. I heard about Antman's rant and I took a close look at those deals.

I don't want to fight or argue about it. We will agree to disagree. If PR and PPG say good deal that's good enough for me.

[Godzilla]

Not looking to tank any deals. It's a wide open playground here. Build away I say.

[PigsRule]

Hurricanes Trade:

Nico Hischier, $2.3m (2018-2021-EL-FP-3.0 )  18-19 Approved

Blues Trade:

Alexander Radulov, $2.8m (2017-2020)
Jakob Silfverberg, $4.2m (2018-2021)

I'm making this trade to give this group one last shot at the title this year before we have to rebuild. This is a trade that will be a win for me in 19-20 but won't look good in a few years when Nico reaches his ceiling.

Denise51 to confirm and thanks for the deal.

Fntxd

[PsychoticPondGoons]

Hurricanes Trade:

Nico Hischier, $2.3m (2018-2021-EL-FP-3.0 )  18-19 Approved

Blues Trade:

Alexander Radulov, $2.8m (2017-2020)
Jakob Silfverberg, $4.2m (2018-2021)

I'm making this trade to give this group one last shot at the title this year before we have to rebuild. This is a trade that will be a win for me in 19-20 but won't look good in a few years when Nico reaches his ceiling.

Denise51 to confirm and thanks for the deal.

Fntxd

CAR & STL done