Yea, I'm not completely unconvinced that both Shooter and SlackJack aren't AI...
What about a compromise like this:
1) 1st round draftees are NOT eligible as Keepers
2) GM's may keep any number of players drafted by their actual team from rounds 2 and beyond (no reason to limit to 3 - it's not like we have space to keep that many anyway)
3) Increase Supp Draft to 4 rounds
4) Adopt Corey's idea of limiting prospect extensions to 3 years, but Keeper's may be extended to 4 or 5.
By taking the 1st rounders out of the Keeper pool, a lot of the disparity we're talking about would disappear. That and we'll make the Supplemental a lot more interesting.
I like this idea too. this would mostly eliminate the need for us to switch our home team to get better keepers and would help even out this disparity. it would definitely increase the value of draft picks in trades. if we did this we should consider add a couple of minor spots