Scoring for pitching

[rcankosy]

I vote yes to new scoring, and I propose that we use the following blend of old and new methods to ease the pain of the change.

New/Old

50/50 in 2012
75/25 in 2013
100/0 in 2014

[h4cheng]

i also vote yes for the change. for those who are voting no, can you please provide some feedback, so we can make some adjustments if necessary.

[Jake]

Are we looking for RC voting only? Or all members?

[Dan Wood]

RC but I think we need a #7

[Colby]

I vote yes to new scoring, and I propose that we use the following blend of old and new methods to ease the pain of the change.

New/Old

50/50 in 2012
75/25 in 2013
100/0 in 2014

 

[Dan Wood]

Do you guys have the annual progressions worked out on a spread sheet somewhere?

[h4cheng]

Just to clarify, my vote is to change it to a combination of current system and game score, with 50/50 weighting.

My personal opinion is that 50-50 is the optimal weighting; it combines both the sabremetric theory with reality. I am not prepared to go to a complete game score system.

[Dan Wood]

Howe what does it look like with 50-50 weighting?

[h4cheng]

Howe what does it look like with 50-50 weighting?

Dan, please see attached. Column Y and Z.

[Dan Wood]

I will agree to the change but here are my stipulations...

-We go 50/50 immediately or we don't go at all
-The Scoring for pitching is never brought up again, is never complained about again, and is not messed with again, because this exercise is becoming absurd.

If we can get 3 more votes to support that, then lets move forward with this and not move back...

If passed I want a detailed write up of the new scoring system, so that I can most it a PM it to the league