ProFSL: Pro Fantasy Sports Leagues

Fantasy Leagues => Franchise GM: Rules Changes => Franchise GM: History Books => Franchise GM => MLB Leagues => Franchise GM: Clarifications & Discussion => Topic started by: rcankosy on September 17, 2012, 03:18:54 PM

Title: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: rcankosy on September 17, 2012, 03:18:54 PM

Guys,

After carefully reviewing all of the suggestions posted in the last thread and taking into consideration the administrative requirements, I would like each of you to vote for one of the following two options, so we can resolve this matter:

1.  Cutting the existing rookie bonuses by 50%.  Consider this the Moneyball League option.

2.  Eliminate rookie bonuses altogether.  It might detract a little from strategy, but it makes things easy and theoretically allows the best talent to reach the hands of those that need it the most.

I am sorry, but separate draft budgets are simply not feasible with the amount of work involved, so I eliminated option # 5 and # 6 from the prior thread.  Also, I do not believe that it will be necessary to spread bonuses if we go with option # 1, so I eliminated option # 3 and # 4. 

Thanks,

Roy 

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: Colby on September 17, 2012, 03:48:20 PM

1) No.
2) Yes.

At this point, the rookie bonuses mess with the reality of the league.  The bonuses only apply for the very end of one year, so they only hit the books to cause people to drop players.  How is that realistic?

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: Dan Wood on September 17, 2012, 04:23:23 PM

I vote with Colby

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: VolsRaysBucs on September 17, 2012, 09:10:22 PM

I am in agreement with Colby as well.

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: shooter47 on September 17, 2012, 09:15:30 PM

1) Yes
2) No

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: rcankosy on September 17, 2012, 09:18:10 PM

Put me down for # 2 as well, so the current tally is 4-1 in favor of eliminating rookie bonuses.

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: h4cheng on September 17, 2012, 09:46:09 PM

1) Yes
2) NO

Title: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: Brewers GM on September 18, 2012, 12:16:49 AM

My vote is no change needed, manage your cap with bonuses calibrated to what happens in MLB in mind. 

If the issue is unrealistic dumping of cap the we can make proposals to address that, like counting the bonuses towards the following season instead.  If small market teams just don't have enough space to be fair then they don't for regulars either and we need to address the cap.

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: kungfuwig on September 18, 2012, 01:15:36 AM

I personally like it how it is, if we could give everyone a draft budget that is the same that would be cool. If not I would vote for cutting the bonus in half for the players.

Title: Re: Final RC Vote on Rookie Bonuses
Post by: rcankosy on September 18, 2012, 07:59:04 AM

I see this vote as 4-3-1, because Ben chose to leave things as is.  Therefore, we are eliminating rookie bonuses.